click again for full view

This is an image of my son’s girlfriend we’ll just call her Her senior pic taken by an unknown photographer to me, yet nice just didn’t feel right the more I looked at it.. So being the graphics person I am, I decided to take and play with it some in my Paint Shop Program.. if you look closely, there are very subtle differences in the original and the retouched version. I softened the skin eliminating the grainy look, and highlighted the shirt a bit more to show a touch of color and detail as well the tree trunk she was leaning against..

  What is your opinion? Original better or retouched version for sure?

 Same with above image as well..?